Plateforme Level Extreme
Abonnement
Profil corporatif
Produits & Services
Support
Légal
English
Oh my, Hamas
Message
De
28/01/2006 22:13:27
 
 
Information générale
Forum:
Politics
Catégorie:
Autre
Titre:
Divers
Thread ID:
01091111
Message ID:
01091232
Vues:
20
>>>>>>>Like all seismic events, this is both shocking and unsurprising. Thoughts?
>>>>>>
>>>>>>Since the majority of the Palestinians have given their vote to Hamas, it is now acceptible to state that the Palestinians are terrorists and evil people.
>>>>>
>>>>>I will take this as ironic and not discourse at this point.
>>>>
>>>>Oh please, do not take this as ironic! At best it is cynical, but I'm also quite serious and thoughtful here. Thoughts is what you asked for, didn't you? Remember how Hitler came to power and how we called 'the Germans' since then? Generalization is everywhere and, although it does no justice to certain individuals, it is not that bad a principle as many declare. Sometimes it is better to hold all people of a 'nation' accountable. Suppose that the majority of the Dutch would vote for a Hitler-like person, and I was an opponent. And you would then call the Dutch bad people. I would fully understand that and feel ashamed for being Dutch.
>>>
>>>The Hitler analogy may be apt. A significant (30-40%) minority is so fed up it votes for extremism. This invariably works out badly, but the pulse of the public has its say.
>>>
>>>What I am about to say will probably alienate me permanently from some here, thinking of Tamar in particular. (Tamar, I ask your forgiveness in advance -- you are one of my faves). I think Israel is a horrible ally. They have brought the U.S. nothing but trouble. 9/11 would not have happened if not for our persistent bias for Israel in the endless resentment between Jews and Muslims. We shouldn't be sticking our necks in. Leave them to their endless resentments. To those who are committed enough to care so much about it, move there and duke it out. Don't bring foreign fights to our shores.
>>
>>So, now you suggest that the attack on the Twin Towers is afterall the responsibility, the guilt, of the Jews and even the Americans themselves! And you also hold a plea for non-interventionism and isolationism? I think many bad people in the world would celebrate that, terroristic movements foremost. But the progress of the world, think of trade and internet and the UT, would also come to an end. And in the mean time there would be a dramatic increase of injustice and cruelty on almost every continent, in almost every not-so-democratic country. Not just for some, but for the masses, because dictators would come to power and stay there, for sure.
>>
>>That reminds me of a saying I've read today in my newspaper. It is written by a columnist who has always been a non-interventionist, but now has turned into an interventionist:
>>
>>Having clean hands doesn't necessarilly mean you have a clean conscience.
>
>
>I am not blaming it on "the Jews" exactly. What I am saying is 9/11 would not have happened if not for our (the U.S.) persistent bias for Israel in the middle east. I think we should lose that policy in the deepest part of the deepest ocean and try to live in peace. We have a bunch of warmongers (or chickenhawks, I should say, since none of them served) in the White House and they have taken us down the wrong path.

You call it 'persistent bias'. I call it 'persistent help to a good cause'. It's all a matter of "whose side are you on". Your usage of the word bias suggests a scientific analysis, but in fact it's not. You have just chosen for 'the other side'. I'm glad that the majority in your democratic country is still on the side of the Israeli.
Groet,
Peter de Valença

Constructive frustration is the breeding ground of genius.
If there’s no willingness to moderate for the sake of good debate, then I have no willingness to debate at all.
Let's develop superb standards that will end the holy wars.
"There are three types of people: Alphas and Betas", said the beta decisively.
If you find this message rude or offensive or stupid, please take a step away from the keyboard and try to think calmly about an eventual a possible alternative explanation of my message.
Précédent
Suivant
Répondre
Fil
Voir

Click here to load this message in the networking platform