>>>So it replaces one theory with another?
>>
>>So you're willing to completely discard a theory without giving it a critical read? That statement also weakens your argument as well, since a theory is a theory is a theory.
>
>Well you've been replying like the theory you want me to read is fact.

You're doing the same with your theory. I've read both theory, then taken the one with the most support. You've taken the only one that you've read.

>I don't see aneed to bother.

Good policy.