>This is what Murtha is proposing when he asked for a complete withdrawl of all troops. I don't know if any of the conservative sites you read discuss Murtha, but today on Huffingtonpost is the text of a speech he gave yesterday. It calls for withdrawing all troops and assembling them as a massive force outside Iraq.

Won't happen and won't be discussed. Because in case of a withdrawal, who will guard the oil? Halliburton?

Now I see the last sentence can be read as "will Halliburton guard the oil" and also as "who will guard Halliburton". Let it be, both need an answer.