Level Extreme platform
Subscription
Corporate profile
Products & Services
Support
Legal
Français
Am I dumb or what
Message
From
19/10/2006 19:25:43
Hilmar Zonneveld
Independent Consultant
Cochabamba, Bolivia
 
 
To
18/10/2006 22:01:03
Neil Mc Donald
Cencom Systems P/L
The Sun, Australia
General information
Forum:
Space
Category:
Articles
Miscellaneous
Thread ID:
01161830
Message ID:
01163516
Views:
25
>>>I'll tell you what to do, try to hold this 1KG magnet at arms length for say 2 hours, you will soon find out how much work is being expended, you will probably drop it after about 20mins due to fatigue, there is a large flow of energy.
>>
>>Sure, you can waste energy this way. You might also conceive of something blowing an object up, using up energy.
>
>So you are saying that there is entropy (wasted energy) when you hold the magnet, but none when it is attached by magnetic attraction to a perpendicular steel plate. Sorry you can't have one without the other.
>
>I ask once again, where does the energy come from that powers the magnetic clamping force.
>
>>No energy, as long as there is no movement.
>
>Ah, a force appied with no energy expended, this would be an over unity process, not possible in the current model.
>
>>You don't need energy simply to maintain a force.
>
>I am sorry but you do need energy to maintain a force, you have just highlighted the flaw in the current model.

You can support a weight with a post, for example. The post doesn't need fuel to continue working - it can continue supporting the weight almost indefinitely.

The only flaw is a confusion between "energy" and "force".

To calculate energy used to move something, you calculate force x distance x cosine of the angle. (If the force is in the same direction as the movement, the cosine of the angle is 1.)

So to support a weight of 100 N, the energy needed (in theory) is 100 N x 0 m x 1 = 0 J. Any energy above that is the result of an inefficient process. Like, using your muscle force instead of a post to support something.
Difference in opinions hath cost many millions of lives: for instance, whether flesh be bread, or bread be flesh; whether whistling be a vice or a virtue; whether it be better to kiss a post, or throw it into the fire... (from Gulliver's Travels)
Previous
Next
Reply
Map
View

Click here to load this message in the networking platform