>>Mike, thanks for inviting us to consider whether RS has done lots for the community... but it's a waste of time, because apparently we're not competent to comment. ;-) Unless I'm very much mistaken, THAT is what Jay is objecting to.
>
>
>Regardless of what anyone else said, or was perceived to say, I never suggested anyone was not competent enough to comment. (In fact I seem to remember saying a few days ago, when it was still about Andy, Marcia, and Naomi, that the opinions of non-MVPs were as relevant as those of MVPs). What I objected to was Jay's "who is this dude, *I've* never heard of him" attitude.

I personally never had that opinion of Jay's responses. Maybe I missed something though.