I agree that NAFTA did cause a "sucking sound as things moved south", but not the GREAT sucking sound Ross Perot claimed.

But that's only because China stepped in ("Socialism with Chinese Characteristics") and WalMart and manufacturers went gung-ho.
They couldn't resist a FULLY-controlled workforce with extremely low wages and tolerance for even poorer working conditions. They couldn't resist that Chinese Pary members retained ownership of factories and signed contrcts for work to be done.
There are 64,000,000 Party Members in China, all benefitting from this boom. Thats a huge market of wel-monied people. The other 1BILLION+ people do what they're told and are told to smile while they do it.

SO it's not NAFTA. The answer to "why?" is greed. Corporate greed and political (U.S. Congress) greed. And it ain't gonna stop until there is no more manufacturing (except posibly defense stuff) in the U.S. Currently, about 10% of jobs in the U.S. are manufturing. Not long ago it ws much higher.



>The economy is down because we have lost our manufacturing base to other countries. Thank you NAFTA, and both Bushes, as well as Bill Clinton for betraying your country economically. It also doesn't help to have the Commander-in-Chief spending like a drunken sailor on payday.
>
>So, the above begs a question to be asked: Why?