>>I have a feeling we should never dine together. ;)
>
>Can we agree on something? Your choice (but should be kosher)?

Picked herring. My mouth waters just typing it.
Chicken cooked in just about any way anybody can come up with (not including with beets or asparagus).
And speaking of chicken, do you eat grieven made with schmaltz? Mmmmmmm...
Potato latkes
Of course, I have no problems with kosher meats - a nice steak.

I didn't exactly grow up on kosher foods, but every year my grandmother cooked up an absolute storm for pesach seder, and did I love that? The woman should have lived forever!