Plateforme Level Extreme
Abonnement
Profil corporatif
Produits & Services
Support
Légal
English
Seeing Eye Dogs
Message
De
28/07/2008 19:40:19
 
 
À
28/07/2008 01:42:20
Dragan Nedeljkovich (En ligne)
Now officially retired
Zrenjanin, Serbia
Information générale
Forum:
Politics
Catégorie:
Autre
Titre:
Divers
Thread ID:
01333768
Message ID:
01334743
Vues:
33
>>>>>>>Then the proper question would be "which door is this"... but what if you wanted to ask what was the door of - is it wooden or iron or plastic... "kakva su ovo vrata?". "What kind of door is this" is not good enough, since I think you'd be PO'd both royally and republicly if you had tried all kinds of, say, fishing rods, and you ask "do you have any other kind", and they give you the same old just made of a different type of plastic. That's not a different kind, is it?
>>>>>>
>>>>>>You'd ask, "Whats' this door made of?"
>>>>>
>>>>>And get the answer "wooden"?
>>>>
>>>>No, and get the answer, "wood".
>>>
>>>So, not the question I was looking for.
>>
>>So, in fact, you're looking for a question to which you already have the answer, and you want to know precisely how to word the question to get the answer you already have?
>
>Yes, because I see no other way of conveying the meaning of the word - it's a querying pronoun, so to say, like "what", "which", "who", "where", and as much as the "who" demands a person in the answer, "which" demands one out of a set, so should this word demand a quality, property... an adjective. So when you ask "--- is the weather", you get a "good", "lousy", "hot"... but not "it's a physical phenomenon studied by meteorology". The trick question for kids was "--- is a black man when he dives out of the Red sea" - the answer would be "wet" (but every now and then a kid would fall for it and say "red" or "black").
>
>Also, alternate line of getting to this word. There are pairs between such pronouns and their answers, like when - then, where - there, which one - that one, and we miss the question side for "such".

Maybe not every answer has a question. Wooden is an adjective, and it would be difficult to formulate a question so specific as to require that the only answer be a specific adjective.
Précédent
Suivant
Répondre
Fil
Voir

Click here to load this message in the networking platform