>>
>>If you think these two processes must be the same, I completely disagree. You really are trying to compare apples to oranges.
>
>
>Michel keeps his process secret even from those axed. MS keeps its process secret even from those axed..... Doens't look like apples and oranges to me.
>
>People here have clamored for information and reasons as to banning. Michel won't budge. Why should MS yield and give him answers when he isn't willing to do the same.
>
>Again, no apples and no oranges.

As an analogy, according to your reasoning, a company's process for firing an employee should be as transparent and public as its process for awarding free cruises to exceptional employees.

If you believe that once someone has been awarded an MVP, then they are automatically entitled to keep receiving it forever, then I might agree with you. But, much as you might wish it to be so, I think you'll agree it isn't.