>>>Yes, your message is reported as sent at 4:42, but it is 6:42 here. I would respect it it reflected the time either here or where the sender actually sent there, but having it reflect the server time then to be confusing. Check settings again.
>>
>>What Time Zone do you have set?
>
>American - central for West Tennessee.

I tried both yours and mine (eastern) time zones and they both work correctly. Try to save settings again.