It's only a bug if it's not done on purpose. VFP and Excel do it that way on purpose, so it's not really a bug, it's just that according to standard math principals, it's wrong.
>try:
>
>?5-2^2
>?-2^2
>
>>>Alan,
>>>
>>>No the whole "negative 1 times" subtopic is obfuscating the discussion.
>>
>>Hmmm... a little bit like saying the fact that I'm old, overweight, and can't jump is obfuscating the discussion that I'm a better basketball player than Kobe Bryant. ;)
>>
>>>
>>>Negative two squared equals positive 4 it's as plain and simple as that.
>>>
>>>Your initial reaction was correct, VFP is correct, and I happen to be correct... to heck with all the opposing naysayers. *g*
>>>
>>>>Agreed. It's not really the negative of 2 squared. It's negative 1 times 2 squared. As far as most of the people posting who say what I'm saying, the info comes from math sources (texts, professors, engineers etc.). I know it seem counter-intuitive and initially, I agreed with your view, but so far, not one legitimate math source I've seen agrees; so afaic, I was wrong, and the texts etc are right.
Previous
Reply
View the map of this thread
View the map of this thread starting from this message only
View all messages of this thread
View all messages of this thread starting from this message only