You and Edward are right. I misremembered what I said.

>A flat tax is the new concept, conceived by those with high incomes who want to less income tax. Well, duh, if self-interest is all one cares about.
>
>
>>BTW, I did not say a flat tax is a new concept. I said a progressive tax is not a new concept.
>
>However, I do agree that Edward does not ever give up a good argument :o)