>>>>>>If it's Palin vs. Obama in 2012 just give her a cigarette and a blindfold. He is about a thousand times smarter than her.
>>>>>
>>>>>Since you are the arbiter of bad writing you know it should be "smarter than she".
>>>>
>>>>Really? I will take your word for it but "smarter than she" sounds a little arch.
>>>
>>>How does "Smarter than her is." sound ?
>>
>>I did not say "Smarter than her is."
>
>No, but the sentence implies it and that is what is taught as the way to remember which is correct. The comparison of "He is smarter" is compared to the noun clause, not to the person. It's a quibble and in speech I often say "He's faster than me." just because it is common usage and if you hadn't shown yourself to be passionate on the subject of good writing by criticizing others' grammatical errors and correcting spelling and punctuation I would never have brought it up <g>.
OK, now I see where you are coming from. If I was a pedant on the grammar of others then I deserve the criticism. When it comes to strict grammar rules I am like you, a democrat ;-) In fact I seem to remember defending one of the non-American members of the UT just the other day, saying give the guy a break, his meaning was clear.
Sincerely, point taken. And can we just drop it? Life is short enough already without people who have been friends shooting arrows back and forth.
Previous
Next
Reply
View the map of this thread
View the map of this thread starting from this message only
View all messages of this thread
View all messages of this thread starting from this message only