>>>>>>http://www.foxnews.com/us/2010/09/02/muslim-soldier-refuses-deploy-afghanistan/
>>>>>>
>>>>>>He should be billed for every expense the military paid for his training, living expenses, transportation expenses, legal expenses, medical expenses, etc before being booted.
>>>>>>
>>>>>>I hope interfering with military readiness can be a chargeable offense against him for causing the military to waste their time on him rather than training an American soldier.
>>>>>>
>>>>>>Let him go fight against us so we can shoot him properly.
>>>>>>
>>>>>>Religion of peace. My butt.
>>>>>
>>>>>Are your sentiments confined to the case in point or to the treatment of concientious objectors in general ?
>>>>
>>>>RE:" As a Muslim, we stand against injustice, we stand against discrimination, and I feel it's my duty as an individual to do this." What the h*ll does he think is the reason for the military to be in Afghanistan? They are there fighting injustice and a lot of other crap. My country has a (relatively speaking) sizable group FIGHTING and rebuilding too. The only injustice I see is he took the oath, and no doubt did it with his left hand on the Quran, and now he is reneging. Send him to Guantanamo to help out. Or, he might like being a medic in a field hospital so he can see what the" 'they are muslims so they must be peaceful " taliban do to our people. What a doorknob, what a knucklehead, what maroon.
>>>
>>>Quite a rant Grady, but it didn't answer my question. OTOH maybe it did.....
>>
>>No it didn't - but it will be interesting to see if you get a straight answer or not.
>>
>>My beef with this case is that the guy's only been in the military a year - so he knew when he joined where the fighting was - so how the heck can he be a conscientious objector now? If that's the case then he shouldn't of joined in the first place - so the "conscientious objector" argument doesn't hold up for me when he volunteered to begin with - all the while knowing where we were fighting....if he had been drafted into service I'd think it'd require a closer look - but not as it stands.
>
>Is there some general rule that states you are not allowed to change your mind about anything within the space of a year ?
>If there is then I, for one, am in serious trouble :-}

In this case - yes - it's called an oath.