I would suggest 'Veronica Mars', 'Eureka', the BBC's 'Sherlock', or 'Firefly' - right off the top of me head

>>BTW, I got seasons 6 and 7 of West Wing and am almost done with season 7.... I'm really going to miss watching this show when we're done.... It is really done well...
>
>Same here. I just finished season 6. Parts of it I was not so crazy about. There are so many new characters it's hard to keep them all straight. And some of the side stories (meteor approaching earth, rancher's war with Canada played for comedy, for example) are the kind of thing that long running series tend to run into. OTOH the Presidential race is compelling. For some reason I expected Santos and Vinick to be good guy / bad guy. In fact they are both very admirable. You said Toby was your favorite character so you must have enjoyed the episodes that featured him.
>
>I don't know what's next for me. There are whole seasons of "Breaking Bad" and "Dexter" (neither of which I think you would enjoy) on the DVR. Or maybe I will go back to watching a whole lot less television. Watching so much TV this spring and summer (Euro 2012 and the Olympics in addition to "The West Wing" has been highly unusual for me.