>>>>Has anyone watched this? (I believe it's CBS)
>>>>
>>>>It looks interesting.
>>>
>>>After seeing "Sherlock," I found I had no interest in an American take on Sherlock Holmes. <g>
>>>
>>>Tamar
>>
>>They both have their place (and adaptation). We watch both.
>
> I like both as well, but have to admit, Elementary is not up to par with Sherlock ...it is good though as long as you don't expect to be watching the UK Sherlock shows (any of them). Benedict Cumberbatch does an excellent Sherlock even better than Jeremy Brett, and Andrew Scott as Moriarty....

Wouldn't even want to try to convince anyone that Elementary was comparable to Sherlock. It's like sometimes you want the prime rib - sometimes a good burger hits the spot.