What's the difference between taxation and confiscation?
>So how do you think things that are public services should be paid for ?
>
>As I understand it many first-world governments confiscate some portion of estates.
>>
>>Some people (myself included) consider "tax" as just a politically correct way to say "confiscate".
>>
>>>Al,
>>>
>>>Up here, we just have a tax on inheritance.
>>>
>>>isn't bill refering just to taxt it? Nobody says the whole amount should be confiscated.
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>Do you think there should be some mechanism whereby Annie can earn back some or all of that $XXX million?
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>Well, there is...
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>She can come up with something like this:
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9_dBep_55mI>>>>>>
>>>>>>Did you think I was not serious?
>>>>>
>>>>>Sorry, Al, for the flip answer.
>>>>>Yes, there is a mechanism.
>>>>>She can earn it.
>>>>
>>>>You said people with lots of money should have done something to earn it.
>>>>
>>>>You misunderstood me - why not have the government hold $XXX million in trust, then when she has "done something to earn it", then she gets it back?
>>>>
>>>>Maybe you mean she should earn $XXX million on her own, then the government will give back $XXX million? Or maybe she only earns $XX or $X millions, the government could match her earnings up to a limit of $XXX million? Not a bad starting point for discussion...
>>>>
>>>>It's very much worth pointing out that, according to your criterion, the
government needs to show that it's worthy of confiscating and making use of $XXX million. That's after making the very debatable assumption it has any right to confiscate any part of an estate built legally from earnings already taxed.
Regards. Al
"Violence is the last refuge of the incompetent." -- Isaac Asimov
"Never let your sense of morals prevent you from doing what is right." -- Isaac Asimov
Neither a despot, nor a doormat, be
Every app wants to be a database app when it grows up