Level Extreme platform
Subscription
Corporate profile
Products & Services
Support
Legal
Français
Conversation with my daughter today
Message
From
28/07/2014 12:02:06
 
 
To
28/07/2014 11:10:14
General information
Forum:
Family
Category:
Children
Miscellaneous
Thread ID:
01604148
Message ID:
01604835
Views:
40
What's the difference between taxation and confiscation?

>So how do you think things that are public services should be paid for ?
>
>As I understand it many first-world governments confiscate some portion of estates.
>>
>>Some people (myself included) consider "tax" as just a politically correct way to say "confiscate".
>>
>>>Al,
>>>
>>>Up here, we just have a tax on inheritance.
>>>
>>>isn't bill refering just to taxt it? Nobody says the whole amount should be confiscated.
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>Do you think there should be some mechanism whereby Annie can earn back some or all of that $XXX million?
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>Well, there is...
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>She can come up with something like this:
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9_dBep_55mI
>>>>>>
>>>>>>Did you think I was not serious?
>>>>>
>>>>>Sorry, Al, for the flip answer.
>>>>>Yes, there is a mechanism.
>>>>>She can earn it.
>>>>
>>>>You said people with lots of money should have done something to earn it.
>>>>
>>>>You misunderstood me - why not have the government hold $XXX million in trust, then when she has "done something to earn it", then she gets it back?
>>>>
>>>>Maybe you mean she should earn $XXX million on her own, then the government will give back $XXX million? Or maybe she only earns $XX or $X millions, the government could match her earnings up to a limit of $XXX million? Not a bad starting point for discussion...
>>>>
>>>>It's very much worth pointing out that, according to your criterion, the government needs to show that it's worthy of confiscating and making use of $XXX million. That's after making the very debatable assumption it has any right to confiscate any part of an estate built legally from earnings already taxed.

9_dBep_55mI
Regards. Al

"Violence is the last refuge of the incompetent." -- Isaac Asimov
"Never let your sense of morals prevent you from doing what is right." -- Isaac Asimov

Neither a despot, nor a doormat, be

Every app wants to be a database app when it grows up
Previous
Next
Reply
Map
View

Click here to load this message in the networking platform