>>Is that your professional opinion as a lawyer and with your deep knowledge of the product and how it was created?
>
>Why do you ask me this question, Al? What is your goal?

You're making statements about Chen's product as if you are a legal expert, and that you have deep knowledge of his product. Neither of those are in evidence at this time. Would you care to elaborate?

>>>Then it makes it potentially legal for him to do and use, along with potentially other Chinese.
>>>
>>>It is illegal for people in the U.S. to download and use, and probably also illegal for most other countries with commerce treaties with the U.S., including European countries.