>I disagree with him because he hasn't given any reason to Not use a form set.

Shawn,

PMFJI here, but, without taking the time to go through all the reasons - please jsut take the advice from MANY of us who know what we're talking about and stay away from formsets. They are NOT a good programming technique, and frankly, reek of "amateurishness" to serious development shops and knowledgeable coders.

Ken