>>Hi Nadya,
>>I vehemently disagree.
>>People who post files are doing so to help others, not to market or maintain a product, which would be released through other means. I don't think it's fair to put any burden on a file's author as to feedback ... the author should be free to indicate a willingness to entertain comments in a README or other mechanism.
>
>The idea of feedback is not to benefit the author, but to benefit those who are trying to wade through the hundreds of available files to find the gems. Simply looking at how many people downloaded the file is only a testament to how attractive the description made the file look (and how long its been available), not whether it's worth a damn.

Erik, I agree 100%. John must be just inundated with feedback ;-) There is always the risk that someone may post malicious feedback - but I guess if that was at odds with the rest of the feedback then anyone with more than two neurons to rub together would smell a rat! Nadya's idea is great.

I've had zero feedback across the board. Despite dropping some seriously big hints that it is welcome (by sheer coincidence see message #429994 posted just three days ago).

Another addition I would like to see is a way of seeing all of an authors contributions at the moment I am relying on the link below.