>Ok, by that standard, all MP3s from Napster are perfectly ok. You _do_ know how Napster works, don't you?

I think that should be "You can copy any copy righted material THAT YOU OWN for your own use". Like your Vinyl and Tape example, perfectly legal. So, when you file share those copies, its not for your own use, which makes EVERYTHING on Napster thats copyrighted illegally there, right?

I'm not a lawyer, just taking a stab at it.