Level Extreme platform
Subscription
Corporate profile
Products & Services
Support
Legal
Français
The Death Penalty
Message
 
To
18/12/2000 08:44:24
General information
Forum:
Politics
Category:
Other
Miscellaneous
Thread ID:
00453737
Message ID:
00454688
Views:
30
>Interesting site though I picked up some mistakes there. (In particular, the part about intercourse with a betrothed woman. If you read the relevant verses, the distinction is made not between whether the woman in engaged or not, but where it occurs. If the act occurs in the city, the woman is deemed to have consented because she could have screamed or otherwise prevented it, but if it occurs in the country ("the fields," I think is the wording), she'd considered a victim because of the isolation. I happened to be in synagogue recently when this was in the weekly reading and the commentary discusses this.)
>
>IAC, what's also only briefly touched on there is how strict the rabbinic rules for capital punishment actually were. Not only were two eyewitnesses needed, but the perpetrator had to have been warned that what he was doing was wrong. IOW, actually executing someone was extremely rare. This is reflected in Israeli practice today, where the only person who's ever been executed is Eichmann.

Yes, I thought that was very interesting, the high standard for capital punishment, and how rare they were. Food for thought for those who look to the bible as a defense of capital punishment.
Chris McCandless
Red Sky Software
Previous
Reply
Map
View

Click here to load this message in the networking platform