Level Extreme platform
Subscription
Corporate profile
Products & Services
Support
Legal
Français
Routing?
Message
From
05/10/2001 13:18:08
 
General information
Forum:
Windows
Category:
TCP/IP
Title:
Miscellaneous
Thread ID:
00564824
Message ID:
00564900
Views:
13
>I recently maintain one NT domain.
>This domain encompasses two subnets separated by a T1 connection.
>My subnet masks are 255.255.255.0 on both.
>I use DHCP and TCP/IP.
>About 8 PCS on office A and about 30 on office B.
>PDC and BDC are in office B, authentication therefore happens
>in office B.
>The two offices are connected through routers with a T1 line.
>Use ethernet within every office.
>
>My problem: If I want to copy files from office A to office B
>it takes very long. It makes sense as the T1 represents a bottleneck.
>T1 at its best is 1.5MBS so I understand.

Your understanding is wrong - T1 is 24B+D, or 1.5Mb - megabits, not megabytes per second. Given framing, latency and protocol overhead, that's approximately 1/8th the speed of a 10Mbps EtherNet connection, and at least 10x worse compared to a 100Mbps Fast EtherNet; the longer the T1 run, the greater the latency, and as a result, the worse the overall throughput on protocols that do not use a windowed transfer protocol, allowing multiple packets to be in transit simultaneously without confirmation.

>When I try to copy a 1MB file from one PC in office B to another PC
>in office B it is instantenous, I don't even get a transfer file window.
>
>When I try to copy a file from an office A PC to another office A PC
>it also takes a long time, the 1MB file takes 10 seconds. I don't understand.

This is because every confirmation, address resolution and authentication request must cross the T1 line to reach the PDC or BDC, and the reply must go back across the T1, a latency delay of ~2x packet transmittal delay per control packet. Setting up a second BDC in office A would vastly reduce the traffic required to cross the T1.

>Maybe I have it set up wrong. Because as I understand it when PC1 in
>office A tries to send a file to PC2 in office A it theoretically should
>go from PC1 to Router in Office A and rerouted to PC2 in office A. That
>would be instantenous. Yet what it seems to be happening is that the packets
>travel all the way to office B and back to office A.
>Can I avoid this?

You need a way of resolving the Windows address without crossing the router; I'd suggest using DNS rather than WINS, and have each router act as a DNS Server for it's local subnet, as well as adding the second BDC. I use a similar approach for some of my clients' multisite implementations.
EMail: EdR@edrauh.com
"See, the sun is going down..."
"No, the horizon is moving up!"
- Firesign Theater


NT and Win2K FAQ .. cWashington WSH/ADSI/WMI site
MS WSH site ........... WSH FAQ Site
Wrox Press .............. Win32 Scripting Journal
eSolutions Services, LLC

The Surgeon General has determined that prolonged exposure to the Windows Script Host may be addictive to laboratory mice and codemonkeys
Previous
Reply
Map
View

Click here to load this message in the networking platform