Level Extreme platform
Subscription
Corporate profile
Products & Services
Support
Legal
Français
VFP vs .NET and To C# or VB
Message
 
To
21/05/2002 09:19:00
General information
Forum:
Visual FoxPro
Category:
Other
Miscellaneous
Thread ID:
00657468
Message ID:
00659336
Views:
67
Hi Ken,

>While I'm all for nicely wrapped functionality explicitely mimicking VFP to accomplish it pays too much homage to a legacy I'm quite willing to leave behind. I want my developers to learn .NET (and in our case - C#), not just write "VFP code" and compile it differently :-).

Call me thick or something, but I just don't understand this mindset. Regardless of it's origin, isn't an additional set of functions a good thing to add to your toolbox? For example, the StrToFile function in the VFP .Net Toolkit takes a string and writes it to a text file, just like it does in VFP. What's the difference behind calling that function INSTEAD of executing the C#/VB.NET code behind it.

Another example is we've developed a number of functions in VB6 that correspond to a VFP counterpart. ALLTRIM() for example. Instead of

Dim MyString As String
MyString = " JIM ""
MyString = LTrim(RTrim(MyString))

we would rather use this line

MyString = AllTrim(MyString)

utilizing this function:

Function Alltrim(ByVal pcString As String)
Alltrim = LTrim(RTrim(pcString))
End Function

My take on this is that whether it's got roots in VFP or not, if I find a function library that works and provides functionality I need to get a job done or be more productive, I'm going to use it.

Just my two cents...
Jim Duffy
Microsoft MVP
INETA Speaker
TakeNote Technologies
Developer's Choice Award Winner for Best Training Company
Specializing in VB.NET, ASP.NET, VFP, and SQL Server Training and Development
Previous
Next
Reply
Map
View

Click here to load this message in the networking platform