General information
Category:
Visual ProMatrix
>>You have 12 billiard balls. All but one of the billiard balls are of equal weight. The one odd bal :) is either lighter or heavier. You do not know which. You have 3 (balance) scale weighings to determine not only which ball is the odd one but also whether it is lighter or heavier. You must be able to give logic for all possibilies.
>>
>>Good Luck. :)
>
Gerald is the winner. Cetin also has a correct response, but Gerald has the most unique response, one that I have never seen before. ( and also with fewer balls on the second weighing. )
The key is to divide the 12 balls into 3 groups of 4 then weigh 2 groups against each other. Namely A, B, C. If you weigh A vs B and they are equal you are the rest is fairly simple. The complication comes when A # B either lighter or heavier. Then you must weigh 5 of the unequal balls against each other. In all cases you must have only 3 unknown balls left. Hence using Gerald's syntax I will show you another possibility. ( Group A (1,2,3,4) is lighter than Group B (5,6,7,8) ). 2nd weighing. l1, l2, l3, h5 vs l4, E9, E10, E11. Once again this limits the unknown balls to 3.
If 2nd weighing =.
Weigh h6 vs h7. If # then the heavier is the winner. If = then h8 is the winner.
If 2nd weighing l1,l2,l3,h5 lighter.
Weigh l1 vs l2. If # then lighter is the winner. If = then l3 is the winner.
If 2nd weighing l1,l2,l3,h5 heavier.
Weigh h5 vs E9. If # then 5 is winner.
If = then l4 is winner.
Thanks all for participating.
Previous
Reply
View the map of this thread
View the map of this thread starting from this message only
View all messages of this thread
View all messages of this thread starting from this message only