>>Does this means that you don't think that there is an advantage or disadvantage in doing it?
>
>Well, I dont really know what it is you are proposing? You asked a similar question to Mel's some time ago and I gave you exactly the same answer. The answer I gave Mel, on the basis of the question he asked, was the obvious way and place to index views in a Codemine CDE.
>
>I cannot see why you would index a view in a Rule class? A rule class is for "rules". You can have a rule class instance on a form if you want. So, I dont associate a rule class with anything other than a place to code potentially re-useable rule logic. A CDE is for data. You cannot index a view until it is opened. Therefore the logical place to index it is after it has been opened. Therefore it follows (to me) that the best method in which to locate your indexing code is in AfterOpenAll.
>
>You have mentioned that Dave gave you this recommendation. Dave wrote the framework so there is no authority higher than Dave regarding his framework. However, I have no idea exactly what question you asked him or in what context you asked it, for him to suggest indexing a view in a Rule class. Beyond that, I cannot express any other view on his recommendation to you.

Thanks for the information. I'm sorry if I gave you the impression that I wanted to put you on the spot here (you against Dave). That was not my intention.