>>>Second, I get the feeling you've got a bit of a bee under your bonnet on this topic, since George Tasker (to name one person) has dismissed your conclusions. However, it's a long way to go from, "fragmentation seems to help in some tests I've done in VFP" to "fragmentation helps most applications most of the time". You'll need to do a (hell of a) lot of testing to establish that - testing that will need to be consistent and repeatable (i.e. the scientific method ;-)) Put some real numbers to your assertions.
>>>
>>>If you don't think developing a fragmenting algorithm would be hard, then try it. The first step would be to write a hard disk emulator and then simulate read/write operations to it.
>>
>>What is the basis for your last statement?
>
>The lack of an alternative - do you have another suggestion?

Are you saying that a Hard Disk emulator is a prerequisite in writing a File Fragmentation Utility? What is the purpose of the emulator?