Plateforme Level Extreme
Abonnement
Profil corporatif
Produits & Services
Support
Légal
English
Gravity Probe B - Update
Message
De
08/07/2004 17:11:07
 
 
À
08/07/2004 08:34:26
Hilmar Zonneveld
Independent Consultant
Cochabamba, Bolivie
Information générale
Forum:
Politics
Catégorie:
Autre
Divers
Thread ID:
00920901
Message ID:
00922241
Vues:
35
>>Hi Hilmar,
>>...
>>are you sure about this? I remember being on an amusement park ride that stands us all up at the outside edge, then it begins to spin. The effect is that people get 'stuck' to the back wall. We certainly did not all end up on top of each other in the middle < s >.
>>
>>Also, I do remember discussions of centrifugal force in physics classes.
>>
>>cheers
>> SNIP
>
>The following is more or less adapted from the physics book I studied in high school.
>
>Let's consider a movement in a straight line first, since this is a simpler case. You are standing on the floor in a train; the train is accelerating. You feel a force that seems to pull you backwards. If the floor is slippery, you will seem to be accelerating backwards - but this is in relation to the train. For an outside observer, however, you are not accelerating backwards, and no force is involved in you being "pulled back", since your natural tendency, due to inertia, is to stay in one place.
>
>Now, if you hold fast to something on the train, you will be accelerated together with the train. This is due to an unbalanced force that pulls you forward. If there really was an equal-but-opposing force pulling you backward (as it may seem), you would not accelerate, due to Newton's first and second laws.
>
>Therefore, we must conclude that the force you feel, which pulls you backward, is an apparent force, or a ficticious force - a fiction which is only required if you assume the train to be an "intertial reference frame", that is, if you assume that it is not accelerating.
>
>If you agree so far, I can proceed - in another message - to compare the case of a circular movement.

As I said, I'm no physicist, but I do DISagree...
When I am on a train or in a car or a plane that is accelerating, I do feel a force pushing me back even if I am in a seat (i.e. holding on to the accelerating object). Maybe it's called "G", not sure, but I am sure it is there.
When the speed stabilizes I no longer feel THAT force.

As regards the effect during circular motion as I described for the amusement ride, I understand that the force is PUSHING ME out from the center and the wall behind me is stopping me and with not much speed at all I can feel 'stuck' in place. That is, I can lift my feet off of the floor and I do not fall to the floor. I attribute this to (what we learned was) the centrifugal force being stronger than gravity at some point.

cheers
Précédent
Suivant
Répondre
Fil
Voir

Click here to load this message in the networking platform