Plateforme Level Extreme
Abonnement
Profil corporatif
Produits & Services
Support
Légal
English
Question for Dragan and Terry
Message
De
02/07/2007 16:24:19
 
 
À
02/07/2007 04:44:25
Information générale
Forum:
Politics
Catégorie:
Autre
Divers
Thread ID:
01236071
Message ID:
01237243
Vues:
15
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>FY enlightenment:
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>" ... I meant something other than what they thought I meant."
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>Not being pedantic or critical. I know you want to improve your English. Despite your protestation to the contrary that whole paragraph was practically flawless till the second-to-last (penultimate) sentence. :-)
>>>>>>
>>>>>>Wow, thanks! However, I dare to protest about 'thought' versus ' think'. I wrote:
>>>>>>
>>>>>>speakers will not ... notice ... I meant something else than they think ...
>>>>>>
>>>>>>The notion is that, in this case, if 'notice' is present tense. then also 'think' must be present tense.
>>>>>>
>>>>>>That's the rule in Dutch. Is it different in English?
>>>>>
>>>>>Ah but you're referring to something that you meant (so they thought).
>>>>>
>>>>>OK would have been:
>>>>>
>>>>>"... native speakers will not always notice that I mean something other than they think I mean."
>>>>>
>>>>>They either think you mean what you mean, or they thought you meant what you meant.
>>>>>
>>>>>You can't meant what you meant, cos they happened at different times.
>>>>
>>>>I don't give up yet. Compare these lines:
>>>>
>>>>"... native speakers will not always notice that I meant something other than they think I meant."
>>>>"... native speakers will not always notice that I said something other than they think I said."
>>>>"... native speakers will not always notice ."
>>>
>>>To me that is the right one. When you say "they think" it implies a continuous action ("I think therefore I am" - doesn't mean I am thinking right at this moment, but the rest of the time my mind's blank). So "they think I said" implies a continuation of their "belief", as opposed to what they thought right at that moment.
>>>
>>>Their noticing will be of something that has passed - what you said. If you said " ...that I say something other than they think I say" implies that this is a slogan, or common utterance of yours (eg an election speech), something you say frequently.
>>
>>In Dutch 'denken' is used both for continuous thinking and for the thinking at a certain moment. There's no restriction there. Are you implying that this is different in English, even in informal conversations and smalltalk?
>
>Yes, in English we have the "continuos" version of a verb, eg "I am walking", suggesting right at this moment.
>
>"I think of you" would mean "a lot of my time is spent thinking of you"
>"I am thinking of you" (used for instance when writing a letter), would mean "As I write this letter my thoughts are of you".
>
>A - "Come inside"
>
>B - "No, I'm smoking" - this would prohibit you from entering because at the moment you have a lit cig in your hand
>B - "No, I smoke" - this wouldn't prohibit you. Just cos you smoke (generally) doesn't mean you can't enter, so long as you're not smoking at the time.
>
>BTW you wouldn't say "I don't give up yet" - you'd say "I'm not giving up yet" :-)

But how about street talk? Are all people really using the "I'm smoking a cigarette" sentence and do they never say "I smoke a cigarette"? I'm not referring here to formal speech, but to street talk. How about...

"I was smoking a cigarette."
"I smoked a cigarette."

>>
>>>Difficult to explain the nuances between languages. eg in English one would say:
>>>"I hope this continues until I am dead" whereas, in French one would say:
>>>
>>>"I hope this continues until I will be dead"
>>>>
>>>>The last doesn't sound right to me.
Groet,
Peter de Valença

Constructive frustration is the breeding ground of genius.
If there’s no willingness to moderate for the sake of good debate, then I have no willingness to debate at all.
Let's develop superb standards that will end the holy wars.
"There are three types of people: Alphas and Betas", said the beta decisively.
If you find this message rude or offensive or stupid, please take a step away from the keyboard and try to think calmly about an eventual a possible alternative explanation of my message.
Précédent
Suivant
Répondre
Fil
Voir

Click here to load this message in the networking platform