Level Extreme platform
Subscription
Corporate profile
Products & Services
Support
Legal
Français
Gun laws
Message
From
11/07/2008 04:44:59
 
 
To
10/07/2008 15:23:01
Walter Meester
HoogkarspelNetherlands
General information
Forum:
Politics
Category:
Other
Title:
Miscellaneous
Thread ID:
01329950
Message ID:
01330459
Views:
26
>>>The more guns are avialable, the more gun deaths. There is not much to deny here.
>>
>>The argument is a false one confusing correlation with causation. It takes the form of X happened and then Y happened. Therefore X was the cause of Y.
>>
>>Death by gun is obviously a gun related death (tautology) but the reason there was a crime committed, regardless of the weapon used, has another cause. You say the cause is gun availability. I say the crime has socio-economic causes.
>
>That abslolutely is a very important factor. But your overlooking the following.
>1. Using the argument that guns make things safer, in the least is an argument not to do anything about socio-economic causes. Which in the end will cause things to get even worse.

I don't recall a post stating that "guns make things safer". This is a generalization of yours. I have read posts from pro-gun members (who are presumably trained in the use of their weapons) stating that they can use guns to defend themselves, something which I can fully agree with. I have friends who I suspect would make short work of any would be attacker who tried to hurt them or their families.



>2. Gun are far more dangerous than the alternatives. Guns are range weapons. You can kill from a distance. There is no skill or force needed to kill someone.

You would be surprised.


>If you take away guns, knives will be used more often in crimes. Since knives are non-ranged weapons (unless you throw them) they are far less deadly.

One teenager killed every 10 days in the UK this year.


>Look I can see things in SA, being totally different as it lacks the governmental bodies to secure the security needed for the citizens to feel safe. But how on earth can the most powerfull country in the world claim that they need guns to keep their society safe. so enlighten me, on why the safety of european countries cannot not be reached in the US ?

Once again this is a twisted version of statements made. No one has said that "the most powerful country in the world claims that they need guns to keep their society safe.". Your anti-Americanism is clouding your thinking. The argument from pro-gun people is first about their belief in their constitutional rights. Secondly about the fact that they can use these weapons for both recreational uses and personal defence. Thirdly, that it is not the gun availability that is the problem but socio-economic problems that give rise to crime and violent crime. You seem to simply not be able, or not willing, to see the difference between the cause of crime in a society and the right to bear arms.


>Why is the US incapable of not getting as safe as up here??

This is finally the right question. Why not explore the historical, social, socio-economic, demographic, and other factors that can contribute to crime in the US and Europe. I suspect that the causes are not gun availability.


>Enlighten me,

That pre-supposes your willingness to give due consideration to alternative points of view.



>What use has the human race for guns? To kill eachother .... and that is not proving to have any respect for human life.
>
>Great...

The entire west, i.e. Europe and North America, are where they are now because of the west's historical, (and now mainly America's continuing), ability to invent, develop, and control military power. Europe (and therefore Holland) is where it is now because of centuries of using (and abusing) power derived from superior weapons, starting with the gun. Let's not kid ourselves about where and how we come to be so "civilized".

What "respect this has for human life" is another discussion entirely.
In the End, we will remember not the words of our enemies, but the silence of our friends - Martin Luther King, Jr.
Previous
Next
Reply
Map
View

Click here to load this message in the networking platform