>>Also, where is the assertion that God "overlooks" our nation?
>
>"One nation, under God" comes to mind. If "under God" does not imply that "God is over us", I suppose it is my knowledge of prepositions that makes it difficult for me to understand religion.
>
OK...there is a fair interpretation on your part. Now, how is the pledge counter to the Establishment Clause?
>>Are you saying that none of this was in the framer's intent? I asked Tamar this question. I will throw it to you?
>
>Are you saying that the framers intent is relevant here?
It can be relevant. I happen to think the framers did intend an abstract reference to God. The question is, which framers am I referring to?
Previous
Next
Reply
View the map of this thread
View the map of this thread starting from this message only
View all messages of this thread
View all messages of this thread starting from this message only